Is a Check Taxed When Received or When Deposited?

Published Categorized as Accounting Method, Federal Income Tax, IRS Audits, Tax, Tax Procedure
deposit check tax income when

It is the last week of December. A customer hands you a check for work you finished months ago. The bank is closed for the holiday, or you are simply busy, and the check sits in a desk drawer until the second week of January.

Which year is that income taxed? Most people would say the year the money hit the bank account. That is how most people keep track of their money. It is also how the IRS reconstructs income when it audits someone who did not keep good books. But that is not the rule in the tax code.

So does it matter when you deposit a check, or only when you receive it? And can the timing rule actually help a taxpayer who is facing an IRS bank deposits analysis?

The recent Tahir v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-119, case provides an opportunity to consider these questions.

Facts & Procedural History

The taxpayers were a married couple. They filed joint returns. They owned operated businesses that ran online storefronts. They were resellers. The businesses bought discounted products from warehouse clubs and other retailers and resold them online.

The businesses were structured as corporations. The husband received W-2 wages from the corporations. For 2020 and 2021, the wages were the only income the couple reported on their returns.

The IRS audited the couple’s income tax returns. The taxpayers did not keep accurate books and records. The IRS agent pulled the taxpayers’ personal bank statements, added up the deposits, and treated the unexplained deposits as unreported income. The IRS issued a notice of deficiency for about $110,000 of tax for 2020 and about $74,000 for 2021 and it proposed accuracy-related penalties. The taxpayers petitioned the U.S. Tax Court to contest the IRS determination.

This is a routine unreported income case. The reason for this post is the defense the taxpayers raised. The taxpayers asserted that the company that employed the husband in 2019 issued several checks to him that were not deposited until 2020. This included checks that the taxpayers said were to reimburse the taxpayer-husband for using his car for the employer’s business and a check for a draw from a rotating savings pool run by a group of friends. The checks were written, and apparently handed over, in 2019, but not cashed until 2020.

When Is Income Taxed for Cash-Method Taxpayers?

Section 61 of the tax code defines gross income as “all income from whatever source derived.” As we have addressed before, this is a broad provision that covers just about any income that results in an incr.ease in wealth This tells us what is taxed–basically everything. It does not tell us when it is taxed.

The timing question turns on the taxpayer’s method of accounting. Most individuals, and many small businesses, are required to use the cash method (the “cash receipts and disbursements method”). Under this method, income is included in the year it is actually or constructively received. That is the rule in Section 451 and the implementing regulations.

“Actually received” is easy enough. If someone hands you cash, you have it. “Constructively received” is the doctrine that keeps taxpayers from avoiding income by simply refusing to pick it up. The regulations say income is constructively received when it is credited to the taxpayer’s account, set apart for them, or otherwise made available so that they can draw on it. There is an exception. Income is not constructively received if the taxpayer’s control over it is subject to “substantial limitations or restrictions.”

Notice what is missing from these rules. There is nothing about the date the taxpayer walks into the bank. Deposit timing is a matter of convenience. The tax code does not consider this as a timing event.

Is a Check the Same as Cash?

So is a check the same as cash for these timing rules? For tax purposes, generally yes. A check is treated as payment when it is received. It is not taxed when it clears. This is not a new rule. The courts settled it decades ago.

As noted by the court opinion in this case, in Kahler v. Commissioner, 18 T.C. 31 (1952), the taxpayer received a commission check after 5 p.m. on December 31. The banks were closed. He reported the check as income for the following year. The court, in a reviewed opinion, held that the check was income in the year he received it. The court said it did not matter that the check was delivered too late in the year to be cashed. Once he had the check, he had the income.

The logic is practical. A check can be deposited, cashed, or even signed over to pay a debt. The person holding it controls it. Delaying the deposit is a choice. And a taxpayer’s choice does not move income from one year to another.

That is also why the familiar year-end move of sitting on checks until January does not work. Many small business owners think they can push income into the next year by holding customer checks in a drawer over the holidays. The textbook answer is that they cannot. If the check is in hand on December 31, it is generally income for that year.

Are There Exceptions?

We are talking about taxes, so naturally, there is one main exception. It applies when there is a real restriction on the check.

Consider Fischer v. Commissioner, 14 T.C. 792 (1950). In that case, the taxpayer received a check for legal services on December 31. The payor was short on funds in the bank. The two agreed that the taxpayer would not deposit the check until after the first of the year. The court held that the check was not income until the following year. The taxpayer could not use the money when he received the check. The agreement was a substantial restriction.

The line between the two cases is the agreement. In Kahler, the only thing stopping the deposit was the clock. In Fischer, the payor asked the taxpayer to wait, and he agreed. Absent this type of arrangement, the check is income when received.

This exception is narrow–if you are reading the rule in a textbook. It comes down to evidence. A taxpayer who wants to rely on it has to be able to prove the agreement. A vague recollection years later that the payor “asked us to hold it” may not be enough.

How Does This Fit With the IRS’s Bank Deposits Analysis?

So how does this fit in with the IRS’s bank deposit analysis? The IRS will often do a bank deposit analysis for income tax audits. This “income probe” is one of the first things it usually does.

The law says that when a taxpayer does not keep adequate records, the IRS can reconstruct income using any reasonable method. The bank deposits method is one of the most common. It starts from the premise that every deposit is taxable income. The taxpayer then has the burden to show which deposits are not, such as transfers between accounts, loans, or repayments of loan principal.

The bank deposits method also has a built-in timing assumption. It assigns each deposit to the year the deposit was made. For most deposits, that is close enough. But it is an assumption. It is not the rule. The rule is still the year of receipt. This gap is where the taxpayers in the present case found some relief.

Can You Lose the Argument and Still Win the Year?

The taxpayers’ main argument about the employer checks was that they were not income at all. They said the checks were car reimbursements. The court did not accept this. The notations suggested the checks were not only for car payments. And the husband’s testimony, standing alone, was not enough to prove they were reimbursements. The court held that the checks were compensation for services and taxable.

But the court then asked a different question. Taxable in which year? The husband testified that the employer kept track of what it owed him and closed out that accounting when he stopped working there in 2019. The court noted that this testimony raised some questions about whether the dates on the checks were accurate. Still, it found credible his testimony that he was paid in 2019. Under Kahler, a check received in one year and deposited in the next is generally income in the first year. Nothing in the record suggested a Fischer-type agreement to delay the deposit. So the roughly $36,000 came out of 2020 income.

The savings pool deposit played out the same way. The court found that the taxpayers had not proven that the $14,000 was a nontaxable return of their own contributions. They had no records of what they paid in, no evidence of the pool’s terms, and nothing showing a continuing obligation to contribute. But the checks dated December 2019, about $5,500, were received in 2019. They too came out of 2020.

The IRS did not address either group of checks in its post-trial brief. The court pointed this out more than once. With nothing from the IRS suggesting an agreement to delay the deposits, the general timing rule applied. Combined with a few other items, the court reduced the IRS’s 2020 income figure by about $69,000. (The taxpayers still lost on most of the other deposits and were still hit with the accuracy-related penalties….)

What About the Prior Year?

This raises the obvious question. If the income belongs in 2019, can the IRS just go tax it in 2019?

Maybe not. The IRS generally has three years from the date a return is filed to assess additional tax. That period is extended to six years if the taxpayer omitted more than 25 percent of the gross income stated on the return. The opinion does not say whether 2019 is still open. But the notice of deficiency in this case was issued in 2024. If the 2019 return was filed on time, the normal three-year window would likely have closed before then.

There are also mitigation provisions in the tax code that can sometimes reopen a closed year when income ends up taxed in the wrong year. Those rules are narrow and come with their own requirements. They do not fit every case. The point is that the year matters. When the IRS puts income in the wrong year, the mistake can cost it the income entirely.

So naturally, timing arguments deserve attention in any audit built on a bank deposits analysis. Deposits made in the first few weeks of January are the first place to look. So are deposits of checks with older dates on them. Those may be income for a year the IRS did not audit, or for a year it can no longer assess.

The Takeaway

The tax code taxes cash-method taxpayers on income when they receive it. The focus is often now on when they deposit it. A check is treated like cash. It is generally income the day it lands in your hands. This is true even if the bank is closed and even if you do not deposit it for weeks. The main exception is a real agreement with the payor to hold the check. This cuts both ways. Holding checks over the holidays will not push income into next year. But when the IRS reconstructs income from bank deposits, it assumes the deposit date is the income date. In this case, that assumption cost the IRS about $41,000 of 2020 income. If you are facing a bank deposits analysis, look at the dates on the checks behind your January deposits. And keep whatever shows when you actually received them.

Watch Our Free On-Demand Webinar

In 40 minutes, we'll teach you how to survive an IRS audit.

We'll explain how the IRS conducts audits and how to manage and close the audit.