Is Your Employee Stock Sale Already on Your W-2?

Published Categorized as Employee Benefits, Federal Income Tax, Tax, Tax Litigation
irs employee award w2

Many employers let their employees buy company stock at a discount. The paycheck deduction is automatic. The shares pile up in a brokerage account. Years later, the employee sells the shares and moves on.

Then tax season comes. The employee gets a Form W-2 from the employer and a Form 1099-B from the broker. Both forms seem to be talking about the same stock. Some of the discount may show up as wages on the Form W-2. The sale shows up on the Form 1099-B. It is easy to assume the Form W-2 already took care of it.

That assumption can be expensive. So what happens when a taxpayer leaves a stock sale off the return because he believes the income was already included in his Form W-2 wages? And what does it take to prove that?

The recent case of Moiseshyn v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-114, provides an opportunity to consider this issue.

Facts & Procedural History

The taxpayer worked as a sales representative for a large medical device company. He participated in the company’s employee stock purchase plan. The plan let employees set aside part of their pay to buy company stock each quarter at 85% of its value. A brokerage firm administered the plan.

The taxpayer bought shares through the plan for about five years. In 2021, the taxpayers sold the shares he had purchased for about $100,000. The broker reported the sale on Form 1099-B. His employer issued a Form W-2. The Form W-2 reported about $272,000 in wages and other compensation.

The taxpayer and his wife hired a return preparer for their 2021 joint return. According to the taxpayers, the preparer believed that everything tied to the employer, including the stock sale, was already reflected in the W-2 wages. So the return did not report the stock sales. There was no Schedule D with the tax return.

The IRS audited the return. The IRS determined that there was about $42,000 of unreported gain from the stock sale and some smaller amounts of unreported dividends and interest. The IRS issued a notice of deficiency for about $7,300 in tax and an accuracy-related penalty.

The taxpayers petitioned the U.S. Tax Court to contest the determination. Before trial, the IRS conceded the penalty. It also agreed to increase the taxpayer’s basis in the shares by about $10,000. This reduced the disputed gain to about $32,000.

How Are Employee Stock Purchase Plans Taxed?

The starting point for income taxes is always whether there is income. The tax code taxes “all income from whatever source derived.” This includes wages. It also includes gains from selling property, like stock.

An employee stock purchase plan blends the two. Generally, the discount the employee gets when buying the stock is compensation. It is a benefit of the job. Any growth in the stock’s value after the purchase is investment gain. It has nothing to do with the job.

Section 423 gives qualified plans favorable treatment. The employee is not taxed when the plan buys the shares, even though the price is below market. Tax waits until the employee sells. What happens then depends on how long the employee held the shares.

If the employee holds the shares for more than two years after the option was granted and more than one year after the shares were purchased, the sale is a “qualifying disposition.” Only a limited slice of the gain is taxed as ordinary income. The rest is capital gain. If the employee sells sooner, it is a “disqualifying disposition.” The full discount at the time of purchase is then ordinary compensation income, and any additional gain is capital gain. Thus, there is a tax rate difference based on timing.

Either way, there are two pieces. There is a compensation piece. And there is a capital gain piece. The sale is not one item of income. It is two items that land on two different tax forms with different tax rates.

Where Does Each Piece Get Reported?

This is where the confusion starts. The employer may include the compensation piece in Box 1 of the employee’s W-2. Many employers do this for disqualifying dispositions. But not every employer does, and not for every sale.

The broker reports the sale on Form 1099-B. The 1099-B shows the gross proceeds. It often shows a basis figure too. But that basis figure usually reflects only what the employee paid for the shares. Brokers are generally not allowed to add the compensation piece to the basis they report.

So, if the employee simply copies the 1099-B onto the return, the compensation piece gets taxed twice. Once as wages on the W-2. And again as capital gain, because the basis is too low. The fix for that is to adjust the basis on Form 8949, not to drop the sale from the return.

Importantly, the Form W-2 never includes the full sale proceeds. And it never includes the investment growth after the purchase date. The growth is not wages. So even in the best case, the Form W-2 covers only part of the income from the sale. The rest has to be reported on the return, and our prior article on reporting ESPPs walks through those reporting rules in more detail.

Who Has to Prove What the W-2 Includes?

In an unreported income case, the IRS has to tie the taxpayer to the income before its determination gets the usual presumption of correctness. That is not a high bar. Information returns like Forms 1099-B, 1099-DIV, and 1099-INT usually do the job.

There is a limit. Under Section 6201(d), the IRS cannot rest solely on an information return if the taxpayer raises a reasonable dispute about its accuracy and cooperates fully with the IRS. Then the IRS has to produce more evidence.

But the taxpayer in this case did not dispute the Form 1099-B. He agreed he sold the shares. He agreed the proceeds were right. His argument was that the income had already been taxed through his Form W-2. That is a different kind of argument. It does not attack the information return. It says the income was reported somewhere else.

Once the IRS shows the income exists, the burden shifts to the taxpayer. The taxpayer has to show, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the IRS got it wrong. That means the taxpayer has to prove that the W-2 really did include the stock income. This is worth pausing on. It is the taxpayer’s job to prove the overlap, not the IRS’s job to disprove it.

Can Plan Materials Prove the W-2 Covered the Stock Sale?

The taxpayer leaned heavily on materials from the broker. One document said that ESPP income “will usually be included” with other compensation in Box 1 of the Form W-2. The taxpayer read this as confirmation that his stock income was in his wages.

The tax court did not agree. The key word was “usually.” The same document also told employees they may have to report ordinary income on a sale and are responsible for reporting it even if it is not on the W-2. So the document said nothing about what actually happened with this taxpayer’s sale. The court said he should have understood the materials did not give him certainty, and that reporting the sale was his responsibility.

The taxpayer also offered the plan summary and plan document. Those did not help either. They described how the plan worked and how to buy stock. They did not say whether the 2021 sale was in his 2021 W-2. And they were the 2024 versions, not 2021.

What was missing? The taxpayer did not have a 2021 pay statement. He testified that he asked his employer for one and could not get it. He did not have anything from the employer showing how the plan income was reported that year. He did not have the name of anyone at the company who could confirm his position. He testified that he felt “caught in the middle,” with the employer and the broker each pointing him to the other. That is a common experience, by the way. Large employers and their plan administrators are not always quick to answer these questions.

The tax court found his testimony credible. But credible testimony about what he believed is not evidence of what the employer actually did. The court noted that it does not have to accept self-serving testimony without documents to back it up. It held the taxpayers liable for tax on the remaining $32,000 of gain.

What Evidence Would Have Made a Difference?

The case shows what not to rely on. It also points to what a taxpayer should have.

The best evidence is the year-end pay statement. It often breaks out stock plan income as a separate line in the year-to-date totals. Employers also have to give employees Form 3922 when shares are transferred under a qualified plan. That form shows the purchase date, the price paid, and the market value on the purchase date. With those numbers, the compensation piece can be calculated and compared to the Form W-2. A letter or email from payroll confirming the amount included in Box 1 would also help. So would a W-2 that separately lists the plan income in Box 14, although employers are not required to do that.

There is also a question the court did not need to answer. The IRS agreed before trial to increase the taxpayer’s basis by about $10,000. The opinion does not say why. One common reason for that kind of adjustment is that part of the discount was already taxed as wages and belongs in basis. If that is what happened, the taxpayer was partly right. Some of the stock income likely was on his W-2. He just could not prove the rest of it was. That is the difference between an argument and evidence.

It is also worth noting that this was a situation for an amended return long before it was a court case. Had the sale been reported with the proper basis adjustment, the result would likely have been far less tax than the IRS proposed, and no fight at all. And once the IRS sends a computer-matching notice, that is the time to gather the pay statements and Form 3922. Records get harder to find as the years pass. As this taxpayer found out, a former employer may not be able to produce a five-year-old pay statement.

The Takeaway

The IRS matches information returns against tax returns. When a 1099-B shows a sale and the return does not, the IRS will assume the income was left out. Saying the income was already in your Form W-2 is a legitimate argument. Sometimes it is even partly true. But it is the taxpayer’s burden to prove it, and general plan materials that say income is “usually” included in wages will not carry that burden. If you sell stock from an employee plan, report the sale on your return and adjust the basis for any amount already taxed as wages. Keep your year-end pay statement and Form 3922 for every year you buy or sell plan shares.

Watch Our Free On-Demand Webinar

In 40 minutes, we'll teach you how to survive an IRS audit.

We'll explain how the IRS conducts audits and how to manage and close the audit.